Titus Makin Jr. Left The Rookie: What He’s Doing Now

When Titus Makin Jr. requested to leave The Rookie after three seasons, his character Jackson West was killed off—but the actor is now thriving as musician Butterfly Ali. The exit turned a popular death into a statement about representation.

Full name: Titus Odell Makin Jr. ·
Born: June 10 1989 ·
Known for: Jackson West in The Rookie ·
Also known as: Butterfly Ali (musical stage name) ·
Years active: 2009–present

Titus Makin Jr.’s career spans television, stage, and music. The table below lays out key biographical data.

Why did Titus Makin Jr. leave The Rookie?

Actor’s request to leave the show

• Makin approached showrunner Alexi Hawley in 2020 after the deaths of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor, expressing discomfort playing a Black police officer without addressing real‑world racial tensions (ScreenRant (entertainment news)).
• He said, “I can’t go play a cop on a show and not talk about the fact that I’m a Black cop. My character hadn’t addressed any of that.” (ScreenRant citing EW)

Behind-the-scenes reasons

• Hawley told TVLine that Makin “wasn’t coming back,” forcing the writers to conclude Jackson’s story (Pajiba (film/TV commentary)).
• The actor prioritized creative authenticity over network safety, a choice that became the exit path.

Bottom line: Titus Makin Jr. chose to leave The Rookie because he couldn’t reconcile his role with the national conversation on policing and race. For fans, the loss of Jackson West was a narrative sacrifice for a real‑world statement.

The implication: leaving a hit show for principle reshaped both an actor’s career and a show’s narrative.

Why was Jackson West removed from The Rookie?

Narrative decision to kill off the character

• Jackson West was killed in the season 3 finale, “A Hole in the World” (ScreenRant).
• Showrunner Alexi Hawley described the death as “heartbreaking” but necessary because the season 3 finale had already set up Jackson for a fatal confrontation (Pajiba via TVLine).

Impact on the show’s storyline

• Jackson’s death removed one of the few Black male leads from an ABC drama — a gap the show attempted to fill later with new recruits.
• Hawley noted they honored Makin’s character as the “heart of the show” in the exit episode (ScreenRant).

Bottom line: Killing Jackson West was the only option once the actor decided not to return. The showrunners turned an actor’s conscience into a plot point — and the writers took a big swing.

The pattern: a conviction-driven exit can open new creative paths while closing old doors.

What is Titus Makin Jr. doing now?

Current music projects under Butterfly Ali

• Since 2020, he has performed as Butterfly Ali, a name inspired by Muhammad Ali (Wikipedia).
• Releases include singles like “Pray for ‘Em”, “5 Minutes”, “Listen to Me”, “Rose”, and “Righteous” (Wikipedia).
• His music blends soul, R&B, funk, and hip hop (Wikipedia).

Social media activity and public appearances

• His Instagram account (@titusmakin) remains active but has not posted new content since early June 2021 (Instagram (Makin’s profile)).
• No public appearances or interviews reported after 2021.

Possible acting future

• Since leaving The Rookie, he has taken small roles in NCIS: Hawai’i and the film On the Come Up (YouTube (interview clip)).
• As of 2025, no new acting projects have been announced.

Bottom line: Titus Makin Jr. shifted his energy from the small screen to a music career as Butterfly Ali. For fans of his acting, the silence on new roles suggests he’s still figuring out his next move — or simply enjoying creative freedom.

The implication: creative conviction can come at the cost of mainstream visibility.

What was Titus Makin Jr.’s role on Glee?

Character David in the Warbler group

• He played David, a member of the Dalton Academy Warblers, a rival show choir (Wikipedia).

Duration of his involvement

• Appeared in multiple episodes during seasons 2 and 3 (2010–2012) (Wikipedia).
• His performance included singing and dancing as part of the Warbler ensemble.

Bottom line: Glee gave Makin his first big break — a singing role in one of TV’s most popular musical shows. It also foreshadowed his later pivot to music as a solo artist.

Is Titus Makin Jr. married?

Known relationship history

• There is no confirmed public information about a spouse or partner (Wikipedia).
• Online speculation exists but no reliable source confirms marriage or children.

Public statements about marital status

• Makin has not addressed his relationship status in any known interview or social media post.

Bottom line: Fans wondering about Titus Makin Jr.’s marital status are left with silence. The actor keeps that part of his life private — and no credible source has filled the gap.

Timeline: Titus Makin Jr.’s career milestones

• June 10 1989: Born in Honolulu, Hawaii (Wikipedia)
• 2009: First acting role in The Suite Life on Deck (Wikipedia)
• 2010–2012: Portrayed David on Glee (Wikipedia)
• 2018: Cast as Jackson West on The Rookie (Wikipedia)
• May 2021: Jackson West killed off; Makin leaves the show (ScreenRant)
• 2021–present: Focuses on music career as Butterfly Ali (Wikipedia)

What’s confirmed, what’s still unclear

Quotes on the departure

“We honored him as the heart of the show. We knew losing Jackson would be a huge blow, but we had to respect his choice.”
— Alexi Hawley, showrunner of The Rookie (ScreenRant)

“He wasn’t coming back, so we had to find a way to conclude his story in a way that felt earned.”
— Alexi Hawley to TVLine (via Pajiba)

“I can’t go play a cop on a show and not talk about the fact that I’m a Black cop. My character hadn’t addressed any of that.”
— Titus Makin Jr. (ScreenRant citing EW)

The implication is clear: Titus Makin Jr. chose authenticity over a steady paycheck. For an actor who grew up in the spotlight of Glee and The Rookie, the decision to walk away from a hit show and into an uncertain music career was risky. For the industry, his departure is a case study in how real‑world pressures reshape on‑screen narratives — and how creative conscience can cost you a role. For fans, the question “what if Jackson West had stayed?” remains unanswered.

Frequently asked questions

Related reading: Ebon‑Moss Bachrach Movies and TV Shows: Full List & Guide · Cast of Gavin and Stacey – Full List by Season and 2024 Special